Clarkslegal LLP - Solicitors in Reading and London

Legal Updates

Genuine substitution does not always rule out employee status

18 January 2019 #Employment

For many years, the law has been clear that an unrestricted right to appoint a substitute is not consistent with employee status.  However, the judgment this month of the Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT) in Chatfeild-Roberts v Phillips & Universal Aunts Limited shows one type of situation where an individual can be found to be an employee despite a substitute being used on apparently regular occasions.

Ms Phillips worked for over three years as a live-in carer for a retired colonel.   When the working relationship ended, she bought employment tribunal claims claiming that she was an employee.  The issue of personal service arose as Ms Phillips had, on several occasions, sent a substitute to carry out her work. The EAT held that although a substitute had regularly been used, this was only when Ms Phillips was on her weekly days off, when she was on annual leave and for a single period of jury service.  On the facts of this case, she was an employee.

The EAT have clearly followed the principle established in Pimlico Plumbers in finding that a right of substitution, exercised only when the contractor is unable to carry out the work, is consistent with personal performance.  This is yet another reminder for employers to avoid placing too much weight on contract wording and to give careful consideration to how such arrangements work in practice. 

Clarkslegal, specialist Employment lawyers in London, Reading and throughout the Thames Valley.
For further information about this or any other Employment matter please contact Clarkslegal's employment team by email at by telephone 020 7539 8000 (London office), 0118 958 5321 (Reading office) or by completing the form on this page.
This information is for guidance purposes only and should not be regarded as a substitute for taking legal advice. Please refer to the full General Notices on our website.

Read more articles

Russell  Dann

Russell Dann

T: 0118 960 4653
M: 0792 014 4165


Employment team
+44 (0)118 958 5321