Clarkslegal LLP - Solicitors in Reading and London

Legal Updates

The AGA Saga continues...an update

10 November 2014 #Real Estate


The recent case of Tindall Cobham 1 Ltd v Adda Hotels [2014] has questioned the position reached by the K/S Victoria v House of Fraser (Store Management) Ltd [2011] case. As we reported in our update “A Guarantor or not a guarantor? That is the question.”  the K/S Victoria case confirmed that a lease obligation requiring an existing group company guarantor to guarantee the lease obligations of an associated assignee company was void.

In the Tindall case the tenants were all members of the Hilton group whose lease obligations under various leases were guaranteed by Hilton Worldwide Inc. The tenants chose to assign their leases to associated companies as part of a corporate restructuring without obtaining landlords’ consents and then argued that the parent company guarantee had fallen away.

The leases contained restrictions on assignment without landlord consent but also provided that consent would be given to an intra-group assignment so long as:-

(a) notice of assignment was given; and

(b) the guarantor gave a fresh guarantee of the incoming tenant’s lease obligations.

The tenants argued that as the second requirement was unenforceable following the K/S Victoria decision they only needed to satisfy the notice test (which they did following completion of the assignments).

The Court of Appeal held that Section 25 of the Landlord and Tenant (Covenants) Act 1995 was not intended to create “an imbalance in... contractual provisions”. As such both requirements were to be disregarded and the specific lease provisions relating to intra-group assignment should be ignored. The tenant was subsequently under an obligation to obtain consent under the standard assignment provisions in the lease.

The decision seems to help prevent Landlords from being left with tenants of a low covenant strength following intra-group assignments. However, the decision could cause concern for tenants where they only have one associated group company who previously guaranteed their position. In that situation a tenant may find it difficult to find a suitable replacement guarantor.

Clarkslegal, specialist Real Estate lawyers in London, Reading and throughout the Thames Valley.
For further information about this or any other Real Estate matter please contact Clarkslegal's real estate team by email at realestate@clarkslegal.com by telephone 020 7539 8000 (London office), 0118 958 5321 (Reading office) or by completing the form on this page.

Read more articles

Simon Ralphs

Simon Ralphs
Partner

E: SRalphs@clarkslegal.com
T: 020 7539 8049
M: 0779 900 7323

Contact

Real Estate team
+44 (0)118 958 5321